How Non-Profits Can Use CRM Systems to Tell Stronger Impact Stories
CRM systems aren’t just for driving revenue, they empower nonprofits to organize, analyze, and leverage their data to demonstrate real impact.
January 16, 2025
Nonprofits are making a real difference in their communities, driving change that matters. But showing that difference can be tricky. It’s not just about how much money was raised or how many new volunteers started, it’s about how those efforts lead to actual, measurable improvements in the community and how it’s driving the mission forward.
It’s not that impact can’t be measured, it’s just that the right systems aren’t always in place to capture and analyze the key data that really shows the difference being made. Disconnected tools—emails, spreadsheets, and donor management systems—scatter information across multiple platforms, forcing small teams to piece everything together manually. With limited time and resources, tracking long-term progress becomes overwhelming, making it harder to clearly show the impact of their efforts.
It can definitely be frustrating, but there’s a better way to do this.
In this article, we’ll walk through four steps to help nonprofits use their CRM system to share stronger, data-backed impact stories.
The Path to Stronger Storytelling
The key to overcoming these challenges lies in how you collect, organize, and report on your data. Which is why a customer relationship management system (CRM) is the ideal solution. CRMs bring all your data together, helping you track and manage the information that matters most to your organization.
We worked with a nonprofit facing these exact challenges. Their systems were scattered, their team was stretched thin, and they needed to keep up with their growing impact. They wanted an easier way to collect and organize their data, and more importantly, they wanted to tell their story in a way that truly reflected the difference they were making.
Once they set out to use their CRM in a more strategic way, the organization was able to centralize its data, allowing it to visualize its impact in real time. They shifted to a data-driven storytelling approach, creating accurate, compelling narratives that resonated with donors, partners, and their greater community. This not only helped them stand out, but it also saved them valuable time and resources. [Read the case study here.]
Below, we’ll walk you through the approach that made this possible and how you can implement these same practices to elevate your own storytelling.
Step 1: Clearly Understand what KPIs and Metrics You Need to Collect
Before you even log into your CRM system, you need a clear understanding of what you want to measure. Your CRM is only as effective as the data you put into it, so defining key performance indicators (KPIs) and metrics that align with your mission is essential.
While this may seem like a basic step, it lays the foundation for everything that follows. Once you’ve identified the right KPIs, you can configure your CRM to capture and organize data in a way that aligns with your analytical needs. This involves customizing fields to store relevant information, defining relationships between key data points, and ensuring data is structured correctly for future analysis.
By structuring your CRM data intentionally, you ensure that your nonprofit collects the right information to tell compelling impact stories later on.
By setting up your CRM in a way that intentionally incorporates your KPIs, you create a system that accurately reflects your organization’s processes and outcomes and makes it easier to extract meaningful insights later on. When it’s time to generate reports, you won’t have to scramble to piece together insights because they’ll already be at your fingertips.
Step 2: Determine What Parts of Your Process Can Be Automated
For nonprofits juggling multiple roles with limited resources, automation is your ally. Automating repetitive tasks allows your team to focus on high-impact activities while ensuring that necessary tasks are still getting done.
To start, assess your current processes. Identify the manual tasks that consume valuable time but don’t require complex decision-making. These are the best candidates for automation. Here are a few common areas to consider:
- Welcome Communications: Any first-time introductions or thank you emails to new supporters
- Donor Management: Follow-ups, acknowledgments, and reporting to keep your donor relationships strong and organized.
- Event Registration and Reminders: Event sign-ups, confirmations, and reminders
- Volunteer Scheduling: Volunteer shift assignments and reminder emails
- Data Entry from Forms: Inputting data from forms
By automating these tasks, you save time and ensure they’re happening smoothly in the background, allowing your team to focus on activities that add more value, such as building donor relationships, engaging volunteers, and analyzing KPIs.
Step 3: Build Out Your Core Reports
Now that your data is organized and your workflows are automated, it’s time to create core reports. These reports should be designed to offer clear insights into your organization’s progress, with the flexibility to adjust as needed.
Let’s say you want to track corporate sponsorships. You could start with a basic report listing all the new corporate partners you’ve gained over the past year. That alone gives you a solid snapshot, but drilling down further provides even deeper insight.
By filtering the report by industry, you might uncover a growing trend—maybe a significant number of new sponsors are tech companies. This insight goes beyond just counting partnerships; it helps you refine your strategy. Now, you can tailor future fundraising efforts to similar companies, highlighting why businesses in that sector find value in supporting your mission.
Even more, by cross-referencing sponsorship data with program impact reports, you could show how tech industry contributions specifically funded new mission initiatives or helped expand programs into new communities. This not only helps you attract more sponsors but demonstrates to existing partners exactly how their support is making a difference.
This flexibility in reporting allows you to draw deeper insights and tell highly relevant stories to different stakeholder groups. The key is to structure these reports to be easily modifiable for future needs. Having these reports ready allows you to respond quickly to changes and make decisions based on real-time data.
Step 4: Review Processes for Additional Efficiencies
The final step is to continuously evaluate your processes and identify further opportunities for efficiency. After reviewing your key reports, look for patterns or areas where your team can improve.
For instance, after analyzing donor engagement trends, you might notice that recurring donors who receive personalized updates about how their contributions are making an impact tend to stay involved longer. This could highlight an opportunity to improve donor retention by implementing more targeted storytelling in your email campaigns.
Additionally, your reports might reveal process inefficiencies. For example, if you see certain types of reports or data collection are taking longer than necessary, it may be time to re-evaluate your workflows.
Regularly reviewing processes allows you to fine-tune your CRM usage, ensuring that you are always optimizing. It also helps ensure that your CRM system is evolving alongside your organization’s needs.
Bringing It All Together
Leveraging a CRM system isn’t just about keeping your data organized, it gives you the tools to make your data work for you. By setting up the right KPIs and metrics, automating time-consuming tasks, building key core reports, and continuously refining your processes, you can turn raw information into powerful impact stories.
Your nonprofit’s story is already compelling, your CRM just helps you tell it in a way that resonates, engages, and drives more support.
Get Insights Sent Straight to Your Inbox
Related Content
